| # |
Player |
Team |
Player's Major League Teams (comments) |
|
| (1)* | William O'Hara | Toronto | Giants, Cardinals |
| (2)* | James McGinley | Toronto | Cardinals |
| (3)* | "Frenchy" LeClaire | Montreal | Rebels, Blues, Terrapins (all Fed. League teams in 1914-15) |
| (4)* | John White | Buffalo | Beaneaters (Jack White; played 1 game with Beaneaters in 1904) |
| (5)* | James Murray | Buffalo | Orphans, Browns, Braves |
| (6)* | Joe Ward | Rochester | Phillies, Highlanders |
| (7)* | Whitey Alperman | Rochester | Superbas |
| (8) | Natty Nattress | Montreal | - (better known as Billy) |
| (9) | Fred Sline | Providence | - (actually William Sline, longtime minor league pitcher) |
| (10) | Royal Rock | Providence | - |
| (11)* | Ray Demmitt | Montreal | Highlanders, Browns, Tigers, White Sox, Browns |
| (12)* | Butch Schmidt | Baltimore | Highlanders, Braves |
| (13)* | Sam Frock | Baltimore | Doves (Rustlers), Pirates |
| (14)* | Fred Burchell | Montreal | Phillies, Americans (Red Sox) |
| (15)* | Jack Kelley | Newark | Cardinals (John B. Kelly) |
| (16)* | Frank Barberich | Providence | Doves, Red Sox |
| (17)* | Frank Corridon | Buffalo | Cubs, Phillies, Cardinals |
| (18)* | Doc Adkins | Baltimore | Americans (Red Sox), Highlanders |
| (19)* | Jack Dunn | Baltimore | Bridegrooms (Superbas), Phillies, Orioles, Giants |
| (20)* | James Walsh | Baltimore | Athletics, Yankees, Red Sox |
| (21)* | Charles Hanford | Montreal | Blues, Whales |
| (22)* | Dick Rudolph | Toronto | Giants, Braves |
| (23) | Curt Elston | Providence | - |
| (24)* | Carl Sitton | Montreal | Naps |
| (25)* | Charlie French | Montreal | Red Sox, White Sox |
| (26)* | John Ganzel | Rochester | Pirates, Orphans, Giants, Highlanders, Reds |
| (27)* | Joe Kelley | Toronto | Beaneaters, Pirates, Orioles, Superbas, Reds, Doves |
| (28) | Benny Meyers | Toronto | - |
| (29) | George Schirm | Buffalo | - |
| (30)* | William Purtell | Montreal | White Sox, Red Sox, Tigers |
| (31)* | Bayard Sharpe | Buffalo | Beaneathers (Doves), Pirates |
| (32)* | Tony Smith | Toronto | Senators, Superbas (Dodgers) |
| (33)* | John Lush | Toronto | Phillies, Cardinals |
| (34)* | William Collins | Newark | Doves (Rustlers), Cubs, Superbas, Buffeds |
| (35) | John Phelan | Providence | - |
| (36)* | Edward Phelps | Toronto | Pirates, Reds, Cardinals, Giants |
| (37)* | Rube Vickers | Baltimore | Reds, Superbas, Athletics |
| (38)* | Cy Seymour | Baltimore | Giants, Orioles, Reds, Braves |
| (39)* | Shadow Carroll | Montreal | Highlanders |
| (40)* | Jake Gettman | Baltimore | Senators |
| (41)* | Luther Taylor | Montreal | Giants, Bronchos |
| (42)* | Walter Justis | Jersey City | Tigers |
| (43)* | Robert Fisher | Newark | Dodgers, Cubs, Reds, Cardinals |
| (44)* | Fred Parent | Baltimore | Perfectos, Americans, White Sox |
| (45)* | James Dygert | Baltimore | Athletics |
| (46)* | Johnnie Butler | Jersey City | Brewers, Cardinals, Superbas |
| (47)* | Fred Mitchell | Buffalo | Americans, Athletics, Phillies, Superbas |
| (48)* | Heinie Batch | Rochester | Superbas |
| (49)* | Michael Corcoran | Baltimore | Reds |
| (50)* | Edward Doescher | Jersey City | Cubs, Superbas, Reds (Jack Doscher) |
| (51)* | George H. Wheeler | Jersey City | Reds |
| (52)* | Elijah Jones | Jersey City | Tigers |
| (53)* | Frank Truesdale | Buffalo | Browns |
| (54)* | Fred Beebe | Buffalo | Cubs, Cardinals, Reds, Phillies, Indians |
| (55)* | Louis Brockett | Buffalo | Highlanders |
| (56) | Robert G. Wells | Jersey City | - |
| (57)* | Lew McAllister | Buffalo | Spiders, Tigers, Orioles |
| (58)* | Ralph Stroud | Buffalo | Tigers, Giants |
| (59) | Vernon Manser | Rochester | - |
| (60)* | James S. Holmes | Rochester | Athletics, Superbas |
| (61)* | Rube Dessau | Rochester | Doves, Superbas |
| (62)* | Fred Jacklitsch | Rochester | Phillies, Superbas, Highlanders, Terrapins, Braves |
| (63) | Stanley Graham | Rochester | - |
| (64) | Noah Henline | Baltimore | - |
| (65)* | Chick Gandil | Montreal | White Sox, Senators, Indians |
| (66)* | Tom Hughes | Rochester | Highlanders, Braves |
| (67)* | Joseph Delehanty | Toronto | Cardinals |
| (68)* | George Pierce | Providence | Cubs, Cardinals (George Pearce) |
| (69) | Bob Gaunt | Baltimore | - (career minor league pitcher) |
| (70)* | Edward Fitzpatrick | Toronto | Braves |
| (71)* | Wyatt Lee | Newark | Senators, Pirates |
| (72)* | Rube Kissinger | Jersey City | Tigers (Charles "Rube" Kisinger) |
| (73)* | William Malarkey | Buffalo | Giants |
| (74)* | William Byers | Baltimore | Cardinals |
| (75)* | George Simmons | Rochester | Tigers, Highlanders, Terrapins |
| (76)* | Daniel Moeller | Rochester | Pirates, Senators, Indians |
| (77)* | Joseph McGinnity | Newark | Orioles, Superbas, Giants |
| (78)* | Jack Hardy | Montreal | Naps, Cubs, Senators |
| (79) | Bob Holmes | Newark | - |
| (80) | William Baxter | Buffalo | - |
| (81)* | Chester Spencer | Rochester | Beaneaters |
| (82)* | Bradley Kocher | Toronto | Tigers, Giants |
| (83)* | Robert Shaw | Toronto | - |
| (84)* | Joseph Yeager | Montreal | Bridegrooms (Superbas), Tigers, Highlanders, Browns |
| (85) | Tony Carlo | Newark | - (Anthony Carlo; from Mexico; never a major leaguer) |
| (86)* | William Abstein | Jersey City | Pirates, Browns |
| (87)* | Tim Jordan | Toronto | Senators, Highlanders, Superbas |
| (88) | Dick Breen | Jersey City | - |
| (89)* | Lew McCarty | Newark | Superbas (Robins), Giants, Cardinals |
| (90)* | Harry Curtis | Montreal | Giants |