| 
 Set Summary
 
Produced by Colgan Gum Company of Louisville, Kentucky 
Round player portrait discs about the size of a silver dollar
Black & White photos with printed ads on back
Distributed with chewing gum in round tin containers
Three distinct sets (see table below for detailed comparisons) 
Two obscure variations include "Square" & "208" Colgans
Premium offer on backs of E270-1 and E270-2 Chips
Rare Premium was a 10-by-18-inch NY Giants Team Photo
 
 
References:1) John Spano, "1909-1913 Colgan’s Baseball Sets: Packed with 'The Gum That's Round,'" Old Cardboard (Issue #19, Spring 2009, p. 26-33)
 2) Lew Lipset, "E254, E270 Colgan's Chips," Encyclopedia of Baseball Cards, (1984, Volume 2, p. 72)
 
 
 
| Colgan's Chips Sets Compared |  | ACC Designation | E254 | E270-1 | E270-2 |  | Year Issued | 1909-11 | 1912 | 1912-13 |  | Example of Card Front |  |  |  |  | Example of Card Back |  |  |  |  | Subset Nickname | Stars of the Diamond | Red Borders | Tin Tops |  | # of Cards in Set | 226 | 185 | 227 |  | Border Style | Borderless | Deep Red | Borderless |  | Message on Back-Top | Stars of the Diamond | Send 25 Box Tops ... | Send 25 Tin Tops ... |  | Value Multiplier | 1 | 3 | 3 |  |